It’s probably pretty clear how I feel about the Paleo Diet.
Of course, nothing is ever black and white with me, especially when it comes to food. While generally I don’t support the Paleo diet as a whole {mostly the way it’s interpreted}, there are a few redeeming qualities about it. One of the standouts: very few people try the Paleo Diet and say, “wow I really feel like crap now”. Instead, it’s quite the opposite. Here are a few reasons why I like it:
1. It provides clear guidelines.
There’s nothing I hate more about the “diet” mentality than rules that state whether foods are “good” or “bad”. Foods don’t have personalities- they can’t be good or bad. What’s more, you can’t really single out specific foods, it’s more about the big picture: how much and how often you eat certain foods, and what your diet looks like as a whole.
That being said, a lot of people looking to make an overhaul to their diet or health in general need a structured framework to get started. They need someone {or something} giving them a green or red light on what they should or shouldn’t eat. It’s easier to break old patterns and habits if you have a clear cut outline to follow, especially in the beginning.
2. It looks beyond fat, carbs, and calories.
There’s so much more to good nutrition than grams of fat or net carbs. The Paleo diet doesn’t harp on calorie counting, tracking macronutrients, or being rigid about portion sizes. Instead, the paleo diet focuses on quality and type of food. By getting rid of the detrimental aspects of the Standard American Diet, you eliminate the need to nitpick on numbers.
3. It slaps dairy in the face. {Sometimes}.
Dairy’s no good for you. It’s inflammatory, mucous-producing, bone-sucking, and autoimmune-destroying. {Yeah, yeah, I’d be the first one to dig into a mound of goat cheese if my son wasn’t allergic to it, but I’ve never claimed to follow a perfect diet.;)} With years and years {and millions of dollars} of “drink more milk” messages crammed down our throats, I’m glad something popular is calling it out for what it is. I only wish it didn’t file it into a gray area. That doesn’t mean there’s NO room for dairy- I just think we all need to be a little more educated about it- it’s not the ONLY {or best} source of calcium.
4. It looks deeper than just nutrients & into absorption.
I don’t love that the Paleo diet cuts out major food groups like beans and all grains {as opposed to just gluten-containing grains}, but I do love the theory behind this: beans and grains contain elements that interfere with nutrient absorption. It’s not just about what you eat, it’s about how your body processes it. You can eat all the good things in the world, but if your gut can’t absorb them, it’ll do you no good. The emphasis the Paleo diet makes on intestinal health and how a healthy vs damaged gut digests foods is fantastic.
5. It’s making health “cool”.
I hate that it takes a fad to do it, but anything –anything- that gets people focusing on the bigger picture of their health gets a check in my book.
All that being said, sometimes I think “going Paleo” would make my life a lot easier- it meets all the needs of my son’s diet- no dairy, no soy, no gluten. Except for the whole not loving meat thing {although I’ve definitely added more in to increase my choices while breastfeeding}. <—Yup, there may be a connection to the allergy thing there, dontcha think? But I digress…
What do you like/not like about the Paleo and other similar diets?







{ 16 comments… read them below or chime in }
ok Im not paleo BUT the more I research and read and learn….Im pretty damn close even in my plain ole mindful eating
MIz Just blogged…Im in love with Sweet Relish!
Do you have a post more about dairy and why it’s so terrible? I enjoy it, but don’t know much about why it’s supposedly so bad. I am an “everything in moderation” kind of gal, though, so maybe that’s why
Brittany (Healthy Slice of Life) Just blogged…A Wonderful Day
I’ll work on one
I am glad that you can see some good points in Paleo. I definitely eat a Paleo style diet, but I try to focus on fresh fruit, no gluten, no dairy & no soy. I just eat the way that makes me feel my best….and sometimes that includes a big chocolate bar!
Maureen Just blogged…What Doesn’t Kill Me Makes Me STRONGER
I thought you said no food is good or bad but then you call dairy bad?? I like dairy and I don’t think it is bad for you.
AHHHHH HA HA HA HA HA HA HA!!!!! Boxing match between Paleo and Dairy! Love it… and I LOVE that Paleo does that because dairy to me is COMPLETE poison!
GiGi Eats Celebrities Just blogged…Throw a Touchdown Pass at the Grocery Store
I do like that it’s actually sparked a debate, but I do still think most people miss the mark on meat. I’m doing the whole food vegan thing now and it’s fantastic. But people tell me I’m crazy and should do paleo. Anything that gets people away from processed foods I can get behind, but you have to do it right.
Carolina John Just blogged…So good I can’t come up with an effective Title
How can you be a balanced RD and denounce dairy? Personal beliefs are great, but what about studies dealing with the good in dairy consumption. I’m very disappointed with your review and frankly what you stand for as well. I don’t plan on reading your blogs or even considering your advice again.
What about the studies that link dairy with type-1 diabetes, cancer, and auto-immune disease? Just pointing out there’s another side to the story.
Ellie-Over-react much?
Don’t even get me started about people on the “paleo” diet. The provide fine lines part, I know a ton of people that are trying to eat “more” paleo. That doesn’t sound like a fine line to me. You don’t hear people saying, I’m trying to eat “more” vegan. Either you do or you don’t. Aslo paleo contradicts itself because I know many paleo books that allow Whey protein even though that comes from milk. It’s very crossfit/elitist to me, like if your not paleo your not doing it right, but many of those people don’t even follow it 100%. I love the idea of eating simple food, but wish people would make of their mind to follow it 100% or not claim to be trying to follow it at all.
Alex (@alexbridgeforth) Just blogged…Cheese Spread Hummus {#vegan} #WIAW 106 {30JAN13}
Why should it matter if people are following it 100%? I actually APPRECIATE people who don’t follow it 100%. They are seeking the benefits from it, but are allowing themselves not to go crazy in the details of trying to follow it 100%. Going crazy with the details of following it 100% would make me pretty disordered, but I appreciate the good in Paleo and eat it about 80 percent of the time.
I wish people would stop being judgemental and high horse about their diets and others diet.
How about we just let people eat as they see fit?
Lisa @ I’m an Okie Just blogged…Special Birthday Surprise + Santa Clause
I think not following 100% is the exact answer to any diet–> that makes it not a “diet” and just a way of EATING!
Ellie-
If you want more info of why dairy is awful, read ‘The China Study.’ You will never look back.
Great post, Whilst strict adherence is ideal, I think any change people make in their diets is going to be hugely beneficial. There’s no benefit to being harsh on people who don’t stick to it 100%
Suz Just blogged…Arthritis and the Paleo Diet
Yes! Thank you!
Lisa @ I’m an Okie Just blogged…Special Birthday Surprise + Santa Clause